Event

May 13, 2024
Realism through the Back Door: Pierre Duhem’s Energetics

While Pierre Duhem (1861–1916) is now mostly known as an influential general philosopher of science and an early historian of medieval science, he also made significant contributions to theoretical physics, and spent his entire scientific career working on a general thermodynamics or energetics that was meant to include (in a certain sense) also classical mechanics. His own conviction of the correctness of his energetics — in contrast to other theoretical options, esp. atomistic theories — seems to run counter to the prima facie instrumentalist flavour of his main philosophical work The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory. Recently, philosophers have come to appreciate realist tendencies in Duhem’s thought, although the extent of his scientific realism remains controversial. In this talk, I review Duhem’s general philosophy of science, paying particular attention to issues of realism and instrumentalism. I, then, turn to Duhem’s energetics, esp. to the problem of stability, to illustrate one way in which realism and instrumentalism are intertwined in Duhem’s practice of theoretical physics.

Address
MPIWG, Harnackstraße 5, 14195 Berlin, Germany
Room
Villa, Room V005/Seminar Room
Contact and Registration

Link to the Zoom-Meeting: https://zoom.us/j/94690790127 Meeting-ID: 946 9079 0127 no registration required. For more information contact Kseniia Mohelsky officeblum@mpiwg-berlin.mpg.de

About This Series

The seminar series of the Research Group “Historical Epistemology of the Final Theory Program” runs once a month, usually on a Monday at 14:00 in the seminar room of the Villa (Harnackstraße 5). The talks deal primarily with the history, philosophy, and foundations of modern (post-WWII) physics or with wider epistemological questions related to the work of the group. There are no pre-circulated papers.

2024-05-13T14:00:00SAVE IN I-CAL 2024-05-13 14:00:00 2024-05-13 16:00:00 Realism through the Back Door: Pierre Duhem’s Energetics While Pierre Duhem (1861–1916) is now mostly known as an influential general philosopher of science and an early historian of medieval science, he also made significant contributions to theoretical physics, and spent his entire scientific career working on a general thermodynamics or energetics that was meant to include (in a certain sense) also classical mechanics. His own conviction of the correctness of his energetics — in contrast to other theoretical options, esp. atomistic theories — seems to run counter to the prima facie instrumentalist flavour of his main philosophical work The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory. Recently, philosophers have come to appreciate realist tendencies in Duhem’s thought, although the extent of his scientific realism remains controversial. In this talk, I review Duhem’s general philosophy of science, paying particular attention to issues of realism and instrumentalism. I, then, turn to Duhem’s energetics, esp. to the problem of stability, to illustrate one way in which realism and instrumentalism are intertwined in Duhem’s practice of theoretical physics. MPIWG, Harnackstraße 5, 14195 Berlin, Germany Villa, Room V005/Seminar Room MPRG Final Theory Program MPRG Final Theory Program Europe/Berlin public