Event

May 7, 2018
The Causal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

The Causal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (CIQM) was in the first place described by historians as a consequence of the growing influence of Marxism among physicists in Western countries. Indeed, during the 1950s, the core of the group of physicists involved in the Causal program around Jean-Pierre Vigier and Louis de Broglie at the Institut Henri Poincaré was mainly constituted either of members or sympathizers of the PCF. Their works were strongly influenced by critics from Soviet Union against the mainstream interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, the so called « Copenhagen » interpretation. Vigier deplored the abandonment of scientific realism in favour of pragmatism he considered in great part responsible for the crisis in fundamental physics, such as the problem of renormalization. They also put the issue of the interpretation of the theory inside the PCF and created a controversy inside the party which raised the relationship between Marxism and science.
The theory was also part of a more global research program linked with contemporary questions in physics. This point is often forgotten which leads to the erroneous conclusion that the motivation of the IHP group was only ideological and, therefore, their activity was out of science. As early as 1957, in collaboration with Japanese physicists, the group proposed a theory for elementary particles and a method of their classification, in a period in where a standard theory was still missing.
This talk will particularly emphasize the close relationship between metaphysical thought and scientific practice, in what I call the putting in equations of scientific realism, through three concrete examples: the demonstration of the Born’s rule within the framework of the CIQM which lead to a general epistemology, proposed by Bohm and Vigier, called the Theory of levels of organization of nature; the model of extended particles and their classification and, as a synthesis, I will specify the non-trivial signification of a maintenance of classical pictures in Quantum Mechanics.

Address
MPIWG, Harnackstraße 5, 14195 Berlin, Germany
Room
Villa, Room V005/Seminar Room
Contact and Registration

No registration necessary, for further information please contact officeblum@mpiwg-berlin.mpg.de.

About This Series

The seminar series of the Research Group “Historical Epistemology of the Final Theory Program” runs once a month, usually on a Monday at 14:30 in the seminar room of the Villa (Harnackstraße 5). The talks deal primarily with the history, philosophy, and foundations of modern (post-WWII) physics or with wider epistemological questions related to the work of the group. There are no pre-circulated papers.

2018-05-07T14:00:00SAVE IN I-CAL 2018-05-07 14:00:00 2018-05-07 16:00:00 The Causal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics The Causal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (CIQM) was in the first place described by historians as a consequence of the growing influence of Marxism among physicists in Western countries. Indeed, during the 1950s, the core of the group of physicists involved in the Causal program around Jean-Pierre Vigier and Louis de Broglie at the Institut Henri Poincaré was mainly constituted either of members or sympathizers of the PCF. Their works were strongly influenced by critics from Soviet Union against the mainstream interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, the so called « Copenhagen » interpretation. Vigier deplored the abandonment of scientific realism in favour of pragmatism he considered in great part responsible for the crisis in fundamental physics, such as the problem of renormalization. They also put the issue of the interpretation of the theory inside the PCF and created a controversy inside the party which raised the relationship between Marxism and science. The theory was also part of a more global research program linked with contemporary questions in physics. This point is often forgotten which leads to the erroneous conclusion that the motivation of the IHP group was only ideological and, therefore, their activity was out of science. As early as 1957, in collaboration with Japanese physicists, the group proposed a theory for elementary particles and a method of their classification, in a period in where a standard theory was still missing. This talk will particularly emphasize the close relationship between metaphysical thought and scientific practice, in what I call the putting in equations of scientific realism, through three concrete examples: the demonstration of the Born’s rule within the framework of the CIQM which lead to a general epistemology, proposed by Bohm and Vigier, called the Theory of levels of organization of nature; the model of extended particles and their classification and, as a synthesis, I will specify the non-trivial signification of a maintenance of classical pictures in Quantum Mechanics. MPIWG, Harnackstraße 5, 14195 Berlin, Germany Villa, Room V005/Seminar Room Alexander Blum Alexander Blum Europe/Berlin public