Event

Oct 9, 2026
Lost in Translation: The Five Paths of the Emergence of Sound

Abstract

In a forthcoming article, I have provided a first survey of a Śaiva astrological tantra from tenth-century Kashmir titled Yuddhajayārṇava (YJA), the “Ocean of Victory in Battle,” or, more generally, Svaraodaya, the “Emergence of Vocalic Sound.” The latter designation has come to refer broadly in India to the entire field of pneumancy, or divination practices based on the breath. In the thirteenth century, the YJA was also translated into Tibetan, where its legacy includes an impressive body of richly illustrated charts and diagrams derived from the astrological procedures described there.

The present communication will offer a general summary of what we now know of the YJA and its history, before turning to its specific treatment of the “five paths” (pathapañcaka) relating the elements and breaths, and thus forming the basis for the “emergence of vocalic sound.” It will be seen that there are remarkable discrepancies in the treatment of this topic between the Sanskrit text and its Tibetan translation, a notable departure from typical Tibetan translation practices. To attempt to understand the reasons for this will be one of the tasks before us.

Biography

Matthew T. Kapstein studied Sanskrit at the University of California, Berkeley, before completing his Ph.D. in Philosophy at Brown University (1987). He taught at Columbia University and the University of Chicago, before joining the École Pratique des Hautes Études, Paris, as Director of the Study of Tibetan Religions, in 2002. In 2018 he was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. His publications include: The Tibetan Assimilation of Buddhism (New York 2000), The Tibetans (Oxford 2006), The Rise of Wisdom Moon (New York 2009), and, co-edited with Kurtis Schaeffer and Gray Tuttle, Sources of Tibetan Traditions (New York 2013). Tibetan Manuscripts and Early Printed Books (two volumes, Cornell 2024), of which he was editor and co-author, received the Toshihide Numata Book Award in 2024.

The demon Rāhu, cause of eclipse. From a scroll illustrating the Svarodaya diagrams, Tibet, early fifteenth century

The demon Rāhu, cause of eclipse. From a scroll illustrating the Svarodaya diagrams, Tibet, early fifteenth century. Courtesy of the Chaofu Collection.

Address
Max Planck Institute for the History of Science, Boltzmannstraße 22, 14195 Berlin, Germany
Room
Zoom/Online Meeting Platform
Contact and Registration

We welcome both internal and external guests. Registration is only required for in-person attendance. All talks will be streamed via Zoom. For further information about the colloquium series, please contact Luigi Rogora (lrogora@mpiwg-berlin.mpg.de). Feel free to distribute information and Zoom link widely.

Zoom link: https://eu02web.zoom-x.de/j/66209731463?pwd=j207m9mbCasrdxQ6elbakFtYM6xIBG.1

Meeting ID: 662 0973 1463

Passcode: 842051

About This Series

The Tibetan term tsi (“calculation”) represents the broadest term for astral sciences, interconnecting diverse disciplines deeply embedded within the classical Buddhist fields of knowledge. Far from being intellectually isolated, High and Central Asia engaged in dynamic cultural exchanges spanning from India, Tibet and the Himalayas, Mongolia and Central Asia, up to China. Within this framework, distinct streams were synthesized: computational astronomy, tied to the Kālacakratantra, used to model celestial mechanics and construct calendars; astrological systems linked to the Indian Svarodayatantra (Yuddhajayārṇava); and mantic practices like geomancy, which claimed Chinese origins while deeply rooted to local contexts.

Furthermore, by viewing the human body as a microcosm structurally attuned to cosmic movements and earthly shifts, astral sciences enabled an interconnected understanding of change across time, space, and somatic experience, eventually connecting it to medical expertise. These practices flourished mainly within monastic centers but spread through trans-regional encounters, mediated primarily by Tibetan and Mongolian scholars.

The colloquium series “Sky, Earth, and Bodies: Astral Sciences across High and Central Asia” highlights recent contributions to the field and opens critical perspectives on the practical life of science in these regions. Invited speakers will trace the adaptation and transmission of astral knowledge across High and Central Asia. Specifically, the series addresses geography and cartography, astral medicine, astronomy, astrology, and mantic arts as they traveled between sources, languages, places, and people, offering a broader understanding of the history of knowledge across trans-regional Asia.

2026-10-09T14:00:00SAVE IN I-CAL 2026-10-09 14:00:00 2026-10-09 15:30:00 Lost in Translation: The Five Paths of the Emergence of Sound Abstract In a forthcoming article, I have provided a first survey of a Śaiva astrological tantra from tenth-century Kashmir titled Yuddhajayārṇava (YJA), the “Ocean of Victory in Battle,” or, more generally, Svaraodaya, the “Emergence of Vocalic Sound.” The latter designation has come to refer broadly in India to the entire field of pneumancy, or divination practices based on the breath. In the thirteenth century, the YJA was also translated into Tibetan, where its legacy includes an impressive body of richly illustrated charts and diagrams derived from the astrological procedures described there. The present communication will offer a general summary of what we now know of the YJA and its history, before turning to its specific treatment of the “five paths” (pathapañcaka) relating the elements and breaths, and thus forming the basis for the “emergence of vocalic sound.” It will be seen that there are remarkable discrepancies in the treatment of this topic between the Sanskrit text and its Tibetan translation, a notable departure from typical Tibetan translation practices. To attempt to understand the reasons for this will be one of the tasks before us. Biography Matthew T. Kapstein studied Sanskrit at the University of California, Berkeley, before completing his Ph.D. in Philosophy at Brown University (1987). He taught at Columbia University and the University of Chicago, before joining the École Pratique des Hautes Études, Paris, as Director of the Study of Tibetan Religions, in 2002. In 2018 he was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. His publications include: The Tibetan Assimilation of Buddhism (New York 2000), The Tibetans (Oxford 2006), The Rise of Wisdom Moon (New York 2009), and, co-edited with Kurtis Schaeffer and Gray Tuttle, Sources of Tibetan Traditions (New York 2013). Tibetan Manuscripts and Early Printed Books (two volumes, Cornell 2024), of which he was editor and co-author, received the Toshihide Numata Book Award in 2024. i The demon Rāhu, cause of eclipse. From a scroll illustrating the Svarodaya diagrams, Tibet, early fifteenth century. Courtesy of the Chaofu Collection. Max Planck Institute for the History of Science, Boltzmannstraße 22, 14195 Berlin, Germany Zoom/Online Meeting Platform Luigi RogoraAnuj Misra Luigi RogoraAnuj Misra Europe/Berlin public