Data and Material Culture
Data and Material Culture: Finds and Specimens as “Raw Archival Data”
Things—for example specimens, artifacts, trophies, instruments, or commodities, religious or literary texts—all travel. They do so by transferring ideas and facts, physically and epistemically. This paper will stress the importance of material culture in data production and the transformation of knowledge. Focusing on 19th century excavations of ancient Near Eastern archaeological sites by European (primarily German and British) scholars, this paper will investigate the status of archaeological objects as “raw archival data” at the critical point between their excavation and their incorporation in museum collections. The knowledge that was derived from these “data” was the result of a complex selection and transformation process, in which people (e.g. scholars at a museum) attached often multiple meanings to their objects of study. This paper will pay attention to the time and space when the objects seemed to have "no status" and their meaning was still dynamic and negotiable. The paper will ask the following question: What is the connection between data and the physical objects they represent? Can an object be both a carrier of data and data itself? What assumptions and practices are required to transform a physical object into a datum? Do objects become “better” data once they arrive at a final destination where they become objects of study? And finally, what role do epistemic practices, such as the application of visual media in the field and the museum play in turning “raw data” into data of another order?